Recent tragic incidents in Anchorage, where two pedestrians lost their lives after being struck by vehicles, have reignited discussions on the severe legal consequences of driving under the influence (DUI). One of these cases—where JB Matha faces charges including second-degree murder, felony DUI, and multiple other offenses—illustrates just how high the stakes can be when a DUI results in a fatality in Alaska.

For those accused of such crimes, the weight of these charges can be overwhelming. The word "murder" itself invokes fear, painting the accused as reckless and deserving of the harshest penalties. However, the legal landscape for DUI-related fatalities is far more nuanced than it may appear at first glance.

Understanding Death by DUI Charges in Alaska

In Alaska, a DUI resulting in death can be prosecuted in multiple ways, each carrying its own set of consequences:

Manslaughter (AS 11.41.120)

Prosecutors often charge DUI-related fatalities as manslaughter, which is defined as recklessly causing the death of another person. This is a Class A felony, punishable by up to 20 years in prison.

Criminally Negligent Homicide (AS 11.41.130)

If the prosecution believes the defendant acted with criminal negligence rather than recklessness, they may pursue this lesser charge, which carries a maximum sentence of 10 years.

Second-Degree Murder (AS 11.41.110)

The most severe charge that can be applied in a DUI-related fatality. Under Alaska law, a person can be charged with second-degree murder if they exhibit an “extreme indifference to the value of human life.” This charge carries a potential sentence of 99 years in prison.

In the case of JB Matha, prosecutors have opted for the most aggressive charge—second-degree murder—arguing that his alleged actions demonstrated an extreme disregard for human life. If convicted, Matha could face a life sentence.

Why You Need the Best Defense in a DUI Murder Case

DUI-related murder charges are not the same as a simple DUI. This is no longer just a traffic offense—it is a homicide case. And in Alaska, where prosecutors are under immense public pressure to be tough on DUI cases, these charges are pursued aggressively.

With so much at stake, having the right defense attorney can mean the difference between freedom and a decades-long prison sentence. Public defenders are skilled lawyers, but they are often burdened with excessive caseloads. In a murder case, where every minute of preparation matters, a private defense attorney has the ability to dedicate the necessary time and resources to crafting a compelling defense.

Why Eric Derleth Is the Attorney You Need

Attorney Eric Derleth, known as The Trial Guy, has built a formidable reputation for successfully defending individuals charged with DUI-related deaths, including multiple second-degree murder charges. His track record is unrivaled—he has never lost a DUI-related murder case.

Derleth’s strategy goes beyond just challenging evidence. He understands the nuances of forensic toxicology, accident reconstruction, and the psychological elements that play into a jury’s decision-making process. When the prosecution tries to portray DUI-related fatalities as “murder,” they must prove that the defendant’s actions demonstrated an extreme disregard for human life—something that is not always as clear-cut as prosecutors claim.

By hiring Derleth, defendants receive the full weight of an experienced and aggressive defense. He meticulously reviews every aspect of the case, from procedural errors in the arrest to weaknesses in the prosecution’s theory of intent. His ability to challenge expert witnesses, question forensic evidence, and present alternative narratives has resulted in numerous victories for his clients.

The Cost of a Private Attorney vs. The Cost of a Conviction

Hiring a top-tier private attorney like Eric Derleth is undoubtedly expensive. A murder trial requires extensive investigation, expert witnesses, and dedicated legal strategy—all of which cost money. But when the alternative is spending decades in prison, the choice becomes clear.

A public defender, while skilled, often does not have the time or resources to dedicate full attention to a single case. With murder charges, every detail matters. A private attorney has the ability to:

• Conduct thorough independent investigations
• Challenge forensic evidence and expert testimony
• Bring in high-quality accident reconstruction experts
• Craft persuasive narratives that humanize the accused
• Ensure every legal avenue for defense is explored

A conviction for second-degree murder can result in a life sentence. With so much on the line, securing the best possible defense is not just an option—it is a necessity.

What’s Next for JB Matha?

JB Matha is now facing one of the most serious charges in Alaska’s criminal justice system. The prosecution will seek to make an example of him, ensuring the harshest penalties possible. But Matha, like any defendant, deserves a fair trial and a vigorous defense.

If a loved one is facing similar charges, the time to act is now. The sooner an experienced attorney is involved, the better the chances of building a strong defense. Eric Derleth’s history of winning DUI-related murder trials makes him the premier choice for anyone facing these devastating allegations. Don’t let an aggressive prosecution determine the future of someone you care about. Contact Eric Derleth—The Trial Guy—today to ensure the best possible defense in the face of serious DUI charges.